Defining the Problem

New Treatment Option

Demographics

CALL TO ACTION!

Linked References

Defining the Problem

New Treatment Option

Demographics

CALL TO ACTION

Linked References

  

Defining the Problem in Mental Healthcare

Traditionally schizophrenia and related psychotic disorders have been difficult to treat due to long delays in treatment, ineffective medications, a lack of intensive case management and psychosocial support for patients and families. The direct costs of schizophrenia are estimated at 2.35 billion dollars a year. This includes a) health care costs b) administrative costs c) lost productivity d) incarceration costs. Indirect costs of the disease are estimated at another 2 billion dollars. Schizophreniform disorder, bipolar disorder, brief reactive psychosis, organic psychosis, delusional disorder, drug-induced psychosis, psychotic depression and schizoaffective disorder costs the government millions of more dollars annually.

A 1994 healthcare cost study indicates old age and mental disability place the highest demand on healthcare resources in the Netherlands. An examination of mental healthcare in Canada reveals an unheralded crisis which is causing a major burden on Medicare. The following figures highlight the exorbitant cost of 'crisis management', or conventional treatment of neurobiological disease:

The Canadian Coordinating Office for Health Technology Assessment (CCOHTA) reports 300,000 Canadians between 16-30 years of age suffer from schizophrenia. Approximately 70,000 Canadians require ongoing drug therapy to prevent relapse. Schizophrenia accounts for 52% of hospitalizations in individuals aged 25 to 44 and requires greater use of hospital beds than any other medical or surgical condition. Hospitalization rates for bi-polar disorder in general hospitals are increasing in women and men between 15 and 24 years of age. Bipolar patients who have ever been hospitalized are predicted to spend 20% of their lifetime in episodes that last between two and seven months. Tragically, 40-60% of people with a psychotic disorder attempt suicide; whereby 10% succeed at taking their own life. Another 10% of individuals are permanently disabled and dependent on the mental health and social services system for long-term care. It is estimated a shocking 1/3 of the homeless suffer from treatable mental illness like schizophrenia.   

New Treatment Option

A modern approach in the treatment of psychotic disorders emerged first in Australia in the early 1990's followed by similar efforts in Canada in the mid-nineties in several communities (London, Halifax, Calgary and Toronto). A new early intervention clinical research program (Prevention and Early Intervention Program for Psychoses) established in London, Ontario in 1996 by Dr. Ashok Malla and his team, furthered the approach at the Early Psychosis Prevention and Intervention Centre in Melbourne by opening access to the community and setting up a community case identification program. In partnership with the London Health Sciences Centre and the University of Western Ontario, PEPP provided a chance for optimum recovery to youth in London through medical and psychosocial intervention during the initial stages of psychosis. Dr. Malla's work led to his current position at McGill University and Douglas Research Hospital as Head of Clinical Research and Canada's Research Chair in Early Psychosis. More significantly, collaboration between the London program, its parent support group and programs in Toronto, Hamilton, Ottawa and now Montreal, is paving the way for development of early intervention programming in Levis, Vancouver, Winnipeg and other cities.

Although long-term studies are needed to determine the actual amount of healthcare dollars saved by preventative treatment of psychotic disorders, research verifies early intervention programming reduce costly services and loss of productivity. Dr. Chen from Queen Mary Hospital in Hong Kong points out "there is evidence that the long-term cost for patients with a longer [duration untreated psychosis] is more than the cost for patients with a shorter DUP". It has been shown early comprehensive (and initially more costly intervention) may reduce the cost of long-term management of schizophrenia by preventing a chronic course of illness. Newer treatment 'nips psychosis in the bud' with medical and psychosocial strategies to avoid non-adherence to treatment, relapse, hospitalization and disability. PEPP research demonstrates an early intervention approach to the treatment of psychosis achieves a positive outcome in nearly 80% of individuals at the end of two years. A combination of low dose atypical anti-psychotic drugs, assertive case management, counseling, client and family education during a young person's first psychotic occurrence assists in recovery. Overall, the cost of treating psychoses decrease as the need for repeated hospitalization and other problems are minimized. Similar approaches at other centres (e.g. Calgary and Halifax) in Canada and elsewhere (EPPIC in Australia) have produced comparable results.   

It is All About Demographics

As our country had the largest baby boom in the industrialized world and boomers had 6.9 million babies between the years 1980-1995, it is imperative to consider pro-active mental healthcare in Canada. Federal and provincial politicians need to focus their attention on the prevention of mental illness and design a national strategy that includes standardized early intervention diagnostic and treatment guidelines, as well as funding for research and programming. An estimated 9 million youth born in the 1980's, 1990's, 1995-2010 make up the largest cohort since the parent boom in 1947-1966. A whole new generation between the ages 16-35 are vulnerable to brain disease and little is being done about it. It is hard to imagine how government and taxpayers will cope with ever-increasing demands on Medicare and Social Services. What's more, how will young people, families and mental health workers continue to manage with mental health care known to fail Canadians for decades? Those of us, who deal with psychosis everyday, are looking for all levels of government to work together and "…protect, promote and restore the physical and mental well-being of residents of Canada and to facilitate reasonable access to health services without financial or other barriers". It is time to deal with the final frontier and invest in specialized services demonstrated to help youth recover from serious mental illness.

Back to chovil.com index

CALL TO ACTION